In the business of video games, intellectual property is critical to success, and Patents, Copyrights, and Trademarks are the bricks with which your IP portfolio is built. The Patent Arcade is the web’s primary resource for video game IP law, news, cases, and commentary.

Conan Properties Int'l LLC et al. v. Ricardo Jove Sanchez


United States District Court for the Eastern District of New York


Case No. 1:17-cv-00162-FB-RLM, Memorandum and Order of August 15, 2018


 

On August 15, 2018, the court issued its memorandum and order after a motion for default judgment in this case.  Plaintiffs own copyrights and trademarks Conan the Barbarian and six other characters: (1) Kull; (2) Ironhand, also known as Esau Cairn; (3) Bran Mak Morn; (4) Dark Agnes; (5) Solomon Kane; and (6) El Borak. Plaintiffs allege that Sanchez violated their rights by manufacturing, displaying, and selling (or offering for sale) miniature sculptures of these copyright-protected characters on Facebook and Kickstarter. Sanchez offered the sculptures for prices ranging from €27 (about $31) to €10,000 (about $11,425). Plaintiffs submitted a takedown notice under the Digital Millennium Copyright Act (“DMCA”) to compel Kickstarter to remove the sculptures, and Sanchez filed a counter-notice, causing them to remain. Plaintiffs filed this suit.  Sanchez never responded.

While this may seem like a trivial default judgment case, the noteworthy part of this case is how the court treated copyrights in characters.  While the Plaintiffs submitted evidence of literally hundreds of copyright registrations for Conan works and works including the other characters, they did not submit any copyright registrations of the characters themselves.  This is primarily because the U.S. Copyright Office will not register a copyright in a "character."  One can register artwork of a character, but not the character in the abstract.  The court here took note of this, and confirmed that "copyright protection for characters is a result of their embodiment in original works of authorship."

While this result may seem obvious, its still instructive to industries in which characters play a central role, including the video game industry.  Video game developers, by virtue of registering copyrights in the underlying works, namely, video games, also automatically get copyright protection for the protectible characters embodied within those games. One less thing to have to worry about down the road, and one more IP asset at your disposal for future use.

There was also a trademark element to this case, but it was not relevant to our interest in this case.  Curious what the figurines looked like? Here is an image from the defendants Facebook page (taken from the Complaint in this case), allegedly showing the figurine next to a cover of the Conan comic which "inspired" it.



Subscribe

Enter your email address to be notified about new posts (average 1-2 emails/wk).


Lawsuit Updates

View All

Patent Spotlight

View All

Read the Book!

The Patent Arcade’s editors also have literally written the book on video game law. Get your copy today!

Latest News

Read More
GET THE APP ON IOS

Follow Us On
The Web’s Best IP Law Resources
Recognized By

DISCLAIMER

The information on this site is provided for informative and educational use only and should not be relied on as legal advice.  No attorney-client relationship exists by virtue of you reading our blog.  Always consult an attorney if you need specific legal guidance.